Timber vs. Open Water: Two Classic Ways to Hunt Greenheads
Mallard hunting is iconic across North America, but two environments—flooded timber and open water—offer completely different experiences. Each demands unique tactics for calling, concealment, decoy placement, and reading bird behavior. Understanding how to hunt both effectively will help you put more greenheads in the bag all season long.
If you’re looking for guided mallard hunts or want to compare outfitters who specialize in either environment, explore vetted options through Find A Hunt.
Understanding Mallard Behavior in Timber vs. Open Water
Greenheads adapt quickly to the habitat they’re using. The way they finish, respond to calling, and commit to decoys varies dramatically depending on the terrain.
Flooded Timber Mallards
-
Fly lower and slower through tight canopies
-
Expect high calling realism from hunters
-
Look for open pockets or holes to land
-
Rely on sound more than sight to locate ducks
-
Often work in tight, intimate groups
Open-Water Mallards
-
Approach at higher altitude
-
Use visual cues first—decoy spreads must be visible from distance
-
Respond well to high-volume calling
-
Commit best with motion decoys
-
Often mix with divers, pintails, and other dabblers
Hunting Greenheads in Flooded Timber
Timber hunting is loud, close-range, and visual—classic mallard action at its finest.
Finding the Right Timber Hole
Greenheads often funnel into:
-
Open potholes in the trees
-
Natural breaks in canopy
-
Shallow water only a few inches deep
-
Backwater pockets off main rivers
-
Oak flats dropping acorns
The best timber holes provide overhead cover but enough sunlight to illuminate the pocket.
Decoy Strategies in Timber
Less is more in the woods. Common approaches:
-
6–12 high-quality mallard decoys
-
Tight, natural groupings
-
A conspicuous landing pocket front and center
-
A jerk cord for movement
-
No need for spinner wings (often flare birds in tight timber)
Calling in Timber
Timber is where calling shines. Use:
-
Aggressive hail calls to get attention
-
Fast, choppy feed chuckles
-
Cadence-heavy strings
-
Soft finishing calls when birds are hovering over the hole
Make your calling bounce off the trees for realism.
Concealment in Timber
-
Wear dark, bark-tone camouflage
-
Lean against thick trunks
-
Minimize movement—birds are close and watching
-
Keep your face masked at all times
Good concealment is often the difference between birds finishing and flaring.
Hunting Greenheads on Open Water
Open-water hunts range from big lakes to reservoirs, rivers, and marshes. Visibility and motion are everything.
Finding Ducks on Open Water
Look for:
-
Wind-protected coves
-
Points that funnel flyways
-
Shallow flats with aquatic vegetation
-
River bends
-
Rafts of ducks using mid-lake areas
Scout at first light or afternoon loafing hours to locate traffic.
Decoy Strategies for Big Water
Numbers matter more on open water. Effective setups include:
-
2–6 dozen decoys depending on space
-
Mixed mallards with a few divers for visibility
-
Wide J-hooks, U-shapes, or long landing lanes
-
Motion decoys: spinning-wing, splashing, or pulsating units
The bigger the water, the wider and more open your spread should be.
Calling in Open Water
Wind and distance swallow sound, so go louder and more frequent:
-
Strong greeting and comeback calls
-
Loud hail calls for high-altitude birds
-
Mix excited feed chatter with rasp
With big flocks circling high, calling helps draw attention but motion seals the deal.
Concealment in Open Water
-
Use layout blinds, boat blinds, or shoreline hides
-
Brush heavily to break up straight lines
-
Stay low and limit silhouettes
-
Let birds commit before sitting up
Open water birds see EVERYTHING—your hide must be flawless.
Timber vs. Open Water: Which Produces More Greenheads?
Both produce incredible hunts, but each shines under different conditions.
Timber Excels When:
-
Water levels flood the trees
-
Birds are pressured on big lakes
-
Cloudy, low-ceiling days keep ducks flying low
-
Acorns or invertebrates draw birds deep into the woods
Open Water Excels When:
-
Freeze-ups push ducks to big, open areas
-
Strong migration pushes new birds through
-
You need to pull ducks from long distances
-
Birds are feeding heavily on aquatic vegetation
Many seasoned hunters rotate between the two based on weather, scouting, and migration timing.
Gear for Greenhead Hunters
Timber Gear
-
Chest waders
-
Quiet calls with rich tone
-
Dark-pattern camo
-
Jerk string or motionless decoys
-
Shotgun suited for short-range shots (#4 or #2 shot)
Open-Water Gear
-
Boat or kayak (where legal and safe)
-
Dozens of durable decoys
-
Spinner wings or motion rigs
-
Layout blinds or boat blind
-
Longer-range loads (#2 or #1 shot)
Why Consider a Guided Mallard Hunt?
Greenhead specialists often bring:
-
Permanent timber leases or private flooded woods
-
Access to big-water blinds or boat setups
-
Pre-scouted travel routes
-
Large, ready-made decoy spreads
-
Professional calling and dog support
For traveling hunters or those new to mallards, guided hunts remove the guesswork and maximize opportunities.
FAQs: Timber vs. Open-Water Greenhead Hunting
Is timber hunting easier than open-water hunting?
Not necessarily. Timber demands sharp calling and stealth, while open water requires larger spreads and strong scouting.
Do spinning-wing decoys work in timber?
Often no—mallards can flare in tight trees. They’re far more effective on open water.
What’s the best weather for timber hunts?
Overcast, low ceilings, or calm days. Birds travel low and respond to calling extremely well.
How many decoys do I need for open-water hunting?
A couple dozen is minimal; bigger water often requires larger spreads for visibility.
Do mallards fly higher over open water?
Typically yes, which is why motion and calling volume are critical.
Ready to chase greenheads in the woods or out on the big water? Browse outfitters, compare hunts, and book your next mallard adventure through Find A Hunt.
