How to Secure Hard-to-Draw Big-Game Tags
Premium big-game units—famous elk, mule deer, antelope, and sheep tags—are harder than ever to draw. Demand keeps rising while tag numbers remain fixed or decline. But with the right long-term strategy, you can dramatically increase your odds of hunting top-tier areas.
This guide breaks down the smartest application tactics, point-management strategies, and ways to secure quality hunts even when you don’t draw. When you're ready to compare guided hunt options or explore easier-to-access opportunities, browse vetted outfitters at Find A Hunt.
Understand Each State’s Draw System
Every western state uses a different approach. Mastering these systems is the foundation of a smart application strategy.
1. Preference Points
States like Colorado, Wyoming (elk/deer/antelope), and Iowa (whitetail) use points to reward loyalty.
Key insight: High-demand units may take years or decades to draw—plan accordingly.
2. Bonus Points
States like Nevada and Montana weight your odds, but every applicant has a chance.
Tip: More points = better odds, but luck still plays a role.
3. Random Draws
Idaho and New Mexico offer pure luck systems.
Why apply: No point creep. Your odds stay the same every year.
4. Hybrid Systems
Some states mix point-weighting with random tags.
Takeaway: Even beginners can draw premium tags—never skip the random chances.
Build a Tiered Application Strategy
The biggest mistake hunters make is applying only for premium units. Instead, use a Goal-Based Tiered Strategy.
Tier 1: Dream Hunts (Low Odds)
-
Famous elk units (e.g., top Colorado limited units)
-
High-end mule deer or antelope units
-
Sheep, goat, moose tags in western states
Apply every year—you never know.
Tier 2: High-Quality but Achievable Hunts (Moderate Odds)
-
Mid-tier elk and deer units
-
General or limited-entry hunts with realistic point requirements
These should form the core of your yearly applications.
Tier 3: Guaranteed or Easy-to-Draw Hunts (High Odds / OTC / Landowner Tags)
-
OTC elk (in states that still offer them)
-
Private-land or ranch access hunts
-
Easy-draw antelope or cow/cull tags
These keep you hunting consistently while points accumulate.
Use Point Systems Wisely
Don’t Chase Units You Can Never Catch
Point creep can make some hunts effectively impossible. If residents or max-point holders dominate a unit, shift your goal.
Strategically Burn Points
Save points for quality—not “max-point-only” units that may never be reached.
Spread Applications Across States
Apply in 5–7 states for the best results.
Example:
-
Long-term: Nevada, Utah, Arizona
-
Mid-term: Colorado, Wyoming, Montana
-
Short-term: Idaho, New Mexico, general tags
Leverage Landowner Tags (Where Legal)
Some states allow landowners to distribute tags that can bypass the draw.
Common in:
-
Colorado (Landowner Preference Program)
-
New Mexico (EPLUS)
-
Wyoming (limited private-land options)
-
Kansas (whitetail)
Great for:
-
Hunters with limited time
-
Repeat trips with trusted outfitters
-
Guaranteed hunt planning
Consider Guided Hunts for Better Odds
Certain states allocate tags directly to outfitters, improving your chances dramatically.
Outfitter Tag Benefits:
-
Better draw odds
-
Pre-scouted properties
-
Expert guidance in premium units
-
Simplified application processes
Many hunters secure their dream hunts years earlier by applying through trusted outfitters.
Apply for Cow, Non-Trophy, or Management Tags
If your primary goal is experience—not antlers—management tags offer fantastic opportunities:
-
More accessible
-
Great for learning new units
-
Lower pressure
-
Often available annually
These hunts help you build familiarity and skill before chasing a trophy tag.
Don’t Overlook “Sleeper Units”
Some units fly under the radar because they lack hype—but still produce quality bulls and bucks.
Signs of a sleeper unit:
-
Bordering a famous unit
-
Mostly private land with limited pressure
-
Difficult access that deters casual hunters
-
Fewer online success stories
Research these opportunities using maps, harvest stats, and local insight.
Hunt Alternative Seasons
Certain seasons offer better opportunity and lower draw competition:
-
Late-season cow elk hunts
-
Early-season muzzleloader mule deer
-
Archery elk or deer in overlooked units
-
Primitive weapon hunts that limit applicants
Choosing the right weapon or season can turn low odds into realistic opportunities.
Use Harvest Reports & Draw Odds Data
Before applying, study:
-
Success rates
-
Trophy potential
-
Hunter density
-
Historical draw odds
-
Point requirements
-
Season dates
This helps you avoid wasting points and time on unrealistic hunts.
Apply Every Single Year
Skipping a year—even in a state you think you’ll never hunt—reduces your long-term odds dramatically. Many hunters draw premium tags because they stayed consistent and let the random component work in their favor.
Build a Personal Long-Term Plan
A well-structured plan spans multiple years and species. Many hunters set goals like:
-
Harvest an elk every 1–3 years (mixing general and limited-entry hunts)
-
Pursue trophy mule deer every 5–10 years
-
Apply annually for sheep, goat, and moose
-
Mix in affordable antelope hunts to stay active
This keeps you hunting while saving points for special tags.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many states should I apply in?
Most serious western hunters apply in 5–7 states to maximize opportunity and long-term odds.
Is it worth applying for “impossible” units?
Yes—if the state has a random draw component. If it’s pure preference point, consider reallocating.
Do I lose points if I draw a tag?
Usually, yes. Some states use separate preference pools for trophy units or cow tags.
Are outfitter tags guaranteed?
Not always, but they often have much better odds than general public applications.
What’s the fastest way to hunt premium-quality big game?
Landowner tags, outfitter pool tags, or private-land access can dramatically accelerate premium opportunities.
If you'd like, I can turn this into a state-specific tag strategy guide (e.g., Colorado, Wyoming, Arizona) or rewrite an outfitter page that highlights their tag-application assistance and draw odds advantages.
